After the beach, we stopped back at the Airbnb to freshen up and decide where we wanted to eat. We landed on the Oar House and headed over. There was a half hour wait, but the outdoor bar had a few stools available and we partook of the great happy hour specials. 2 large margaritas each later, we were pleasantly buzzed when our table became available. We we sat on the outside deck and ordered fried alligator bites for our appetizer and then split another blackened grouper plate that came with hush puppies, grits, rice, cole slaw, and broccoli. It also came with a side of citrus buerre blanc (that was delish) and we ordered a side of crawfish etouffe. Everything was great...except for the grouper. It was so bad that we asked for a new piece. Our server was super nice and said she had no probably getting us a new piece but it would take about 20-30 minutes. We said forget it. But then she came back saying that the manager wanted to make it right and that he could have the new piece right out. We said ok sure, we’d love a new piece! We got the new piece and it was just as bad as the first. The manager came over and apologized profusely and said that they had been having problems with this batch of fish for some reason. He said he would comp the grouper and told us each to pick out a dessert. So we each got the brownie sundae, and then felt like we were going to explode after all that food lol!